textlize pricing account
[FULL] '엔비디아 칩 안 써' 오히려 중국 반도체가 배짱부리는 이유 (권석준 교수)
Cover

01:08:43

Why China's Semiconductor Industry is Confidently Pushing Forward Without Nvidia Chips

An in-depth analysis of China's strategic response to US semiconductor sanctions and its unexpected path to innovation.

Key Insights

  • China's semiconductor strategy leverages the "paradox of deficiency," turning restrictions into innovation catalysts.
  • Companies like CXMT and SMIC are rapidly closing the technology gap in memory and foundry sectors.
  • DeepSeek's breakthrough in optimizing downgraded Nvidia GPUs demonstrates China's software innovation capabilities.
  • China's massive engineering talent pool and government support create a powerful innovation ecosystem.
  • South Korea faces challenges in maintaining competitiveness due to demographic and educational system limitations.

The Memory Semiconductor Challenge

The global memory semiconductor market, particularly DRAM, has maintained a stable tripartite structure dominated by Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron. However, China's CXMT has emerged as a formidable fourth player, rapidly narrowing the market share gap to within 2-3% of Micron.

While CXMT still lags behind technologically by 2-3 generations compared to Micron and 3-4 generations behind Korean leaders, its strategic importance to China's self-sufficiency goals has made it a "national champion" enterprise. The company's progress in HBM production illustrates this determination:

  • Plans to mass produce HBM2 in the second half of 2024
  • HBM3 production scheduled for 2025
  • HBM3e production targeted for first half of 2027

The Military-Specification Imperative

A critical factor in China's semiconductor strategy is the military's specific requirements. The People's Liberation Army requires military-specification (mil-spec) memory for its servers, creating a guaranteed market for domestic producers. This mirrors the United States' approach of supporting Intel through Defense Department contracts to maintain mil-spec chip capabilities.

CXMT has become indispensable to China's defense infrastructure, as alternative domestic memory suppliers cannot meet the military's requirements. This strategic importance ensures continued government support, even if the company might not be commercially viable otherwise.

The Foundry Revolution

While memory semiconductors get significant attention, China's most substantial progress might be occurring in the foundry sector. The global foundry market ranking has seen dramatic changes:

Rank Company Country
1 TSMC Taiwan
2 Samsung Electronics South Korea
3 SMIC China
4 UMC Taiwan
5 GlobalFoundries USA
6 Huahong Group China

Chinese foundries have rapidly ascended the rankings, with SMIC reaching third place and Huahong Group entering the top six. This progress is particularly notable in legacy and mid-tier processes (10nm and above), which remain crucial for communication chips, power semiconductors, industrial applications, automotive MCUs, IoT sensors, and image sensors.

The Balloon Effect: How Sanctions Backfired

US restrictions on advanced semiconductor equipment created an unexpected "balloon effect" – instead of stifling China's industry, pressure found release in alternative directions. Unable to pursue cutting-edge processes, Chinese foundries redirected massive investment into legacy and mid-tier chip production.

The government's triple subsidy system accelerated this trend:

  1. Subsidies to foundries for construction
  2. Subsidies to encourage using domestic equipment
  3. Subsidies to companies purchasing the resulting chips

This created a thriving ecosystem where domestic equipment manufacturers like Naura and AMEC gained valuable testing grounds and iteration opportunities that would have been unavailable without restrictions.

The DeepSeek Breakthrough: Software Innovation

The most striking example of China's innovative response to restrictions comes from DeepSeek (深度求索). Facing limitations on obtaining high-end Nvidia GPUs, the company achieved remarkable performance with downgraded chips through software optimization.

DeepSeek's breakthrough involved three key innovations:

  • Precision Reduction: Moving from 32/64-bit to 4/8-bit precision for intermediate calculations, dramatically reducing memory requirements
  • Error Management
  • Memory Optimization: Developing dual-pipe technology to maximize input/output bandwidth despite limitations

Surprisingly, DeepSeek open-sourced all these innovations, encouraging widespread adoption and potentially establishing a new ecosystem around their approaches.

Creating Alternative Ecosystems

Beyond hardware restrictions, China is addressing software ecosystem dependencies. Moore Threads (摩尔线程), founded in 2021, is developing MUSA – a CUDA-compatible API that could reduce reliance on Nvidia's software ecosystem.

Similarly, Huawei's expertise in communications is being applied to solve the critical chip-to-chip connectivity challenges that become paramount at scale. Their experience building networks for cities of millions provides valuable topology expertise for connecting thousands of processors efficiently.

Comparative Challenges: South Korea's Position

The interview highlights concerning trends for South Korea's semiconductor competitiveness:

  • Demographic Challenges: Declining birth rates reducing the future engineering talent pool
  • Educational System Issues: Bright students increasingly preferring medical fields over engineering
  • University Funding Constraints: Limited resources for attracting top global talent
  • Cultural Factors: Reduced prestige of engineering careers since the IMF crisis

The contrast with China's approach is stark – with numerous Politburo members coming from engineering backgrounds and the prestigious "academician" system providing social status comparable to corporate chairmanship.

Strategic Implications and Future Outlook

China's semiconductor strategy demonstrates how targeted restrictions can inadvertently stimulate innovation through the "paradox of deficiency." By forcing domestic companies to solve problems differently, the sanctions have accelerated development in unexpected areas:

  • Legacy process optimization
  • Domestic equipment development
  • Software efficiency breakthroughs
  • Alternative ecosystem creation

The situation suggests that complete technological decoupling might be increasingly difficult as China develops competitive alternatives across the semiconductor value chain. For other countries, the challenge will be maintaining innovation momentum while navigating this transformed competitive landscape.

© 2025 textlize.com. all rights reserved. terms of services privacy policy